Get a solar water heater - or else
February 2nd, 2009 by Stephen DownesWhat if every Hawaii home had a solar water heater? Imagine the millions of dollars and barrels of oil saved every year. Imagine the money you'd save on your electricity bill. Surely in sunny Hawaii, a solar water heating system should be as basic as indoor plumbing.
Well, that's what Republican Rep. Gene Ward thinks. And he's willing to make you buy one. House Bill 1836 would require existing single-family homes to be retrofitted with a solar water heating system by an (unspecified) date. If you don't install one, you would be charged a fee for non-compliance.
Perhaps this sounds like a proposal from an overreaching environmental activist. Or maybe even a socialist. But read on...
To make the burden less onerous, Ward offers various ways that make it easier to get a solar system. An increase in state tax credits, from 35 to 50 percent; low-interest loans, leases or grants; or "pay-as-you-save," with no down payment and a monthly charge to your electricity bill. The bottom line: You'll eventually make up the money, and then some, through a lower energy bill. You'll get these savings whether you install a water heater system or photovoltaics. And if there's a good reason not to install one — you live in a dark forest, for instance — the requirement would be waived.
Still not convinced? Read on...
With the incentives, a solar water heater can be had for about $800 dollars, Ward believes. It would pay for itself in less than 1.5 years, and for the rest of its estimated life — maybe 12-15 years — the owner would be pocketing the savings. That's real money, something that wouldn't motivate a true socialist.
But forcing single-family homeowners to install a solar panel just sounds wrong, right? Read on...
There are any number of things that one expects to come with a single-family house; you certainly wouldn't buy one without these basics: Toilets and showers, for instance. A kitchen sink. An oven and stove. Lights. A water heater. So why not a solar one? Converting the masses to a better technology certainly isn't unprecedented. After all, nobody buys records anymore. More and more, it's hard to find a regular incandescent light bulb — they're all CFLs. Analog TVs? Killed by government mandate. And try buying a new car without an air bag.
So why can't the same be done for something that is a plainly superior technology, that could save us least $1 billion of the $7 billion we spend on oil each year? Why can't we adopt a proven, easily available technology currently used by only about 30 percent of Hawaii homes? Why can't we as a 1.2 million-strong community unite to do something that's clearly in our best interests?
Perhaps the time is not right for such a drastic change. Perhaps oil is still too cheap. Perhaps yet another government mandate just sticks in the craw. But let's face it: The state of Hawaii is aiming at a 70 percent clean energy future by 2030. No one doubts that it's a worthy goal. The state is partnering with the federal Department of Energy to implement it. But as Ward correctly points out, without a sustained commitment from all of us, this ambitious plan amounts to little more than a robust handshake. To make it work, we'll have to take serious action.
Perhaps HB1836 simply explains how we're going to do it.
Tags: Department of Energy, Gene Ward, green technology, Hawaii, oil, photovoltaics, Solar energy, tax credit, water heater


February 4th, 2009 at 12:16 pm
A signficant number of Hawai'i homes are in condos or multi-story buildings where the occupant and/or landlord does not own or control the roof space necessary. I wonder how Ward's proposal deals with those.
I think an easier way to 'encourage' people to do things like install solar water heaters is to tax electricity consumption. Heavily. Use some of the funds raised by that tax to provide tax credits and low-interest financing for such things, and use the rest to offset the facilitate the elimination of the GET on food, rent, and medical services, and the increase of the standard deduction for income tax.
The state should also install solar water heaters on all state buildings that use hot water that have suitable roof space.
February 6th, 2009 at 12:10 pm
Here come the everlasting GOP stoppers. By pushing the solar hot water heater they are undermining the market forces that make it worthwhile to finance Photovoltaic systems that could make us truly energy independent.
Leave it to a bunch of know-nothings to screw up an eminent free market paradigm shift.
A day late and half-baked as usual for the GOP stoppers!
February 11th, 2009 at 5:28 pm
Many of older people don't benefit from credits unless it is refundable. Moreover the paperwork is complicated. Furthermore I used to have one that broke after about three years. There was a problem with the photovoltaic water pump that circulated the water to the water heater and the water in the heater would discharge on the side of the roof when the water got too hot. There was nobody to fix it-- the company being out of business. The electrical on the water heater still had to kick in when we used too much of the water in the heater. Any solar water heater sold in this state should be certified to run for 15 years without any maintenance.
The same is true of the pre-heater that I bought to replace the solar heater. Piece of junk. It made a lot of noise and took forever to work at nite. Had to put a timer on it so it wouldn't turn on at nite. The air filter fell apart in the sunshine and the whole thing had to be shut down after a year.
March 23rd, 2009 at 8:48 am
It appears Gene Ward subscribes to the old saying "If you can't lick 'em, join 'em." Government interference in the marketplace is wha caused our eonomic meltdown, but that lesson is lost on those who see government as the controlling power in the marketplace.
If solar water heaters were such a great deal, they wouldn't need the government to force them on people. The marketplace works -- if you let it.
If Gene really wants to use government powers to save money, he could introduce legislation to outlaw the sale of any passenger vehicle with more than four cylinders on Oahu. That would reduce emissions, reduce oil usage, help the auto dealers, and make parking easier since you wouldn't have to cram your car into a space next to a Yukon, driven by a 4 foot nothing girl out buying cigarettes.